The Mahzar: A Critical Examination of a Religious-Historical Document

Ghodratollahi, Ehsan

[Home ] [Archive]

[ فارسی ]

Quartely Research Journal of Islamic History

پژوهش نامه تاریخ اسلام (فصلنامه انجمن ایرانی تاریخ اسلام)

Main Menu

Home

Journal Information

Articles archive

For Authors

For Reviewers

Registration

Contact us

Site Facilities

Search in website

The Iranian Society of Islamic History

index

isc
noormags
magiran
sid
google scholar
virascience
academia
linked in

Volume 1, Issue 60 (winter 2025)

islamhistory 2025, 1(60): 72-75

Back to browse issues page

The Mahzar: A Critical Examination of a Religious-Historical Document

Ehsan Ghodratollahi ^*

Abstract: (6 Views)

In 1579, a manuscript was prepared at the court of the Mughal emperor Akbar (1542–1605) and signed by the highest-ranking state officials and the most prominent religious scholars; it subsequently became known as the Mahzar. In this document, Akbar was introduced as an Imam whose obedience was obligatory, who was deemed the most just, the wisest, and the most knowledgeable of God. Accordingly, in religious matters disputed among the mujtahids, his judgment—provided that it was based on the proper administration of the realm and the improvement of the people’s livelihood—was to constitute the final and decisive ruling. The objective or objectives underlying the formulation of this important religious-historical document have long been a subject of debate and controversy among scholars interested in the history of Muslim India. Employing a descriptive-analytical method, the present study seeks to address the principal question of what motive or motives, in light of the political and social circumstances of Indian society during Akbar’s reign, informed the drafting and official promulgation of this significant religious-historical document, and which of the proposed interpretations most closely corresponds to historical reality. The findings indicate that several considerations may have motivated Akbar to formulate the Mahzar, including acquiring sufficient authority to resolve religious disputes arising in the Ibadat Khana (House of Worship), combining religious authority with political sovereignty, formally proclaiming an independent Islamic caliphate, and attaining the status of divinely sanctioned kingship and the position of Zill Allah (“Shadow of God”). Among these possibilities, the second objective—which also encompassed the first—appears to have been the most prominent. Nevertheless, the pursuit of the third and fourth objectives would not have been implausible for an ambitious monarch such as Akbar.

Keywords: Akbar, Mahzar, Ibadat Khana, religious authority, Muslim India

Full-Text [PDF 556 kb] (3 Downloads)

Type of Study: case report | Subject: Special
Received: 2025/09/3 | Accepted: 2025/11/14

References

1. ‘Allami, Abolfazl (1886). Aein-i- Akbari. Calcutta: Nool Keshvar. [In Persian]

2. ‘Allami, Abolfazl (1886). Akbar Nameh. Calcutta: Nool Keshvar. [In Persian]

3. Atharali, M (1978). “Towards an interpretation of the Mughul empire” JRAS. Vol Xi. Issue. 1.

4. Badauni, ‘Abdol ghader ibn moluk shah (1865). Montakhab- al- Tavarikh. Calcutta: Prince College. [In Persian]

5. Buckler, F.W (1924). “A new interpretation of Akbar’s infallibility”, JRAS, Vol Lvi. Issue. 4.

6. Burke, S.M (1989). Akbar, The greatest Mughul. New Delhi: Ptv Publis.

7. Falahati, Maryam (1392 sh). “Din-i- Ilahi”. The Encyclopaedia of the world of Islam. Tehran: entesharat bonyad daeratolma’aref islami. [In Persian]

8. Fekrat, M.A. (1373 sh). “Abolfazl-i- Allami”. The Great Islamic Encyclopaedia. Tehran: entesharat markaz daeratolma’aref bozorg islami. [In Persian]

9. Graham, Gail. M (1969). “Akbar and Aurangzeb”. The Muslim world. Hartford Seminary Foundation. Vol Lix.

10. Haig, Sir woseley (1937). The Cambridge History of India. London: Cambridge University Press.

11. Ikram, S.M (1965). Muslim Civilization in India. NewYork: Clumbia University.

12. Lane Poole, Stanly (1980). Medieval India under the Mohammadan Rule. New Delhi: Seema Publications.

13. Mahajan, V.D (2005). History of Medieval India. New Delhi: S.Chand and Company Ltd.

14. Pezeshk, M& Seyedhoseinzadeh, H (1385 sh). “Akbar Shah”. The Great Islamic Encyclopaedia. Tehran: Entesharat markaz daeratolma’aref bozorg islami. [In Persian]

15. Politella, Joseph (1966). “Akbar Warrior, devotee and mystic”. The Muslim world. Hartford Seminary Foundation. Vol Lvi.

16. Qureshi, Ishtiyag Husain (1974). Ulema in Politics. Karachi: Ma’refat Limited Publication.

17. Riaz al-islam, M (1373sh). Tarikh-e ravabet-e iran va hend. Translated by Aram & Ghaffari fard. Tehram: Amirkabir. [In Persian]

18. Rizvi, S.A (1983). A history of Sufism in India. Vol II. New Delhi: Munshiram Mohenlal Publishers.

19. Roychaudhury, Makhanlal (1985). Din-i- Ilahi. New Delhi: University of Calcutta.

20. Serrivastava, A.L (1989). The Mughal empire. Agra: Shivalal Agarwal.

21. Seyyed Hoseinzadeh, H (1389 sh). “Badauni, ‘Abdol qader ibn moluk shah”. The Great Islamic Encyclopaedia. Tehran: Entesharat markaz daeratolma’aref bozorg islami. [In Persian]

22. Sharma, Sri Ram (1972). Religious policy of the Mughal emperors. Bambay: Munshiram Mohanlal Publishers.

23. Sharma,Sri Ram (1985). “Akbar’s religious policy”. Indian Historical Quarterly, Vol xiii. New Delhi: CaxtonPublishers.

24. Shiyal, Jamaloddin (2001). The History of the Islamic Government 0f Mughul Emperors in India. Cairo: Eskandariyeh Publication. [In Arabic]

25. Smith, V.A (1917). “Akbar’s house of worship”. JRAS. Vol Xlix. Issue. 4.

26. Smith, V.A (1958). The Oxford history of India. London: Oxford University Press.

Mendeley

Zotero

RefWorks

Ghodratollahi E. The Mahzar: A Critical Examination of a Religious-Historical Document. islamhistory 2025; 1 (60) :72-75
URL: http://journal.isihistory.ir/article-1-1577-en.html

Rights and permissions
	This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

Volume 1, Issue 60 (winter 2025)

Back to browse issues page

Persian site map - English site map - Created in 0.14 seconds with 40 queries by YEKTAWEB 4766